A nurse rolls her eyes at a co-worker as she picks up the assignment sheet that was created by a younger charge nurse. An ICU nurse pretends not to see her co-worker is drowning and ignores her request for help saying she is too busy. A newly hired RN who was previously a scrub tech finds she is now shunned by both groups. Is this just life as a nurse or a nurse's right of passage? Or is it something more insidious? These behaviors go by several names: lateral or horizontal violence, incivility, nurse-to-nurse bullying, sabotage -nurses eating their young.
In general, bullying in the United States is a term used to describe uncivil behavior from someone who has power over you vertical aggression. Rude behaviors from peers are referred to as horizontal or lateral hostility and are defined as: A consistent pattern of behavior designed to control, diminish or devalue a peer (or group) which creates a risk to health or safety (Farrell, 2005).
Some specific examples are:
- Overt. Name calling, bickering, fault finding, criticism, intimidation, gossip, shouting, blaming, put-downs, raised eye brows; and
- Covert. Unfair assignments, refusing to help someone, ignoring, making faces behind someone's back, refusing to only work with certain people or not work with others, whining, sabotage, exclusion, fabrication.
Estimates of lateral violence in the nursing workplace ranges from 100 percent (Stanley et al. 2007). Nursing literature abounds with examples of prevalence.
In one study, one-third of nurses perceived emotional abuse during their last five shifts worked (Roche). In another survey, 30 percent of respondents (n= 2,100) said disruptive behavior happened weekly, and 25 percent said monthly (Advisory.com).
A study of emergency room nurses found that 27.3 percent had experienced workplace bullying in the last six months with many staff bullied by their managers, charge nurses or directors as well as physicians and peers (Johnson, Rea). Bullying behaviors are like gangrene “when tolerated from a few physicians or nurses with strong personalities, the behaviors spread and infect the entire team“ and eventually, the patient.
Lateral violence needs to stop. Bullying behaviors create a toxic work environment which not only harms nurses, but also our patients. Experts agree nursing communication breakdowns and lack of teamwork are a root cause of errors. If nurses are afraid to speak up because they are intimidated by fellow nurses and physicians, patients can be harmed. Research also shows that simply witnessing rude behavior "significantly impacts our ability to perform cognitive tasks" (Porath). From a very ethical perspective, tolerating bullying behaviors is wrong and violates our basic oath to keep patients safe.
But maybe we need another oath? Maybe it's time we promise to keep each other safe; to nurture, support and protect each other because we understand and recognize how vulnerable we all are and the critical role we play in health care.
In April, after accidentally drawing up the wrong medication which resulted in a child's death, an experienced nurse took her own life. Her suicide is a result of our failure as a system, and as a profession, to provide a safe harbor for the delivery of patient care. Who knows what else was going on in her mind, or the details of the situation? All I know is that it could just as easily have been me who made the error.
Where do we start to stop nurse bullying? A Chinese magician once said, If you want to take power away from anything, call it by its name. The overt and covert behaviors listed above are not normal. They are examples of lateral violence that cause serious and long lasting damage to our patients and to each other. They are wrong. Work your magic - say so!
Farrell, G. (2005). From tall poppies to squashed weeds: why don't nurses pull together more? Journal of Advanced Nursing 35 (1): 26-33.
Johnson, S., Rea, R. (2009) Workplace bullying: concerns for nurse leaders. Journal of Nursing Administration Vol. 39, Nov. 2, pp. 84-90.
Pearson, C., Porath, C. (2009) The cost of bad behavior. Penguin Books
Roche, M. et al. (2009). Violence toward nurses, the work environment, and patient outcomes. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, Vol. 42:1, 13-22.
Stanley K., Martin M., Michel Y., Welton M. & Nemeth S. (2007) Examining lateral violence in the nursing workplace. Issues in Mental Health Nursing 28, 1247â€“1265.
Have you seen or experienced nurse bullying in the workplace? What was done about it?